Skip to navigation Skip to main content Click to view our statement on Accessibility

Lines of Business

  • Individuals
  • Businesses
  • Partners

Account

  • About us
    • Our story
    • Company leadership
    • Charitable impact
    • Annual report
    • Research
    • Careers
    • Newsroom
      About us
    • Our story
    • Company leadership
    • Charitable impact
    • Annual report
    • Research
    • Careers
    • Newsroom
  • Contact us
  • Account
    • Zing® Marketplace
    • JM® Shipping Solution login
    • Pay my bill
    • Business claims
      Account
    • Zing® Marketplace
    • JM® Shipping Solution login
    • Pay my bill
    • Business claims
Navy Jewelers Mutual Logo
White Jewelers Mutual Logo

Commercial

  • Protect your business
      Protect your business
    • Business Insurance
        Business Insurance
      • Business Owners Policy
      • Jewelers Block
      • Commercial Umbrella
      • Claims
      Business Protection
      • Business Owners Policy
      • Jewelers Block
      • Commercial Umbrella
      • Claims
    • JM® Shipping Solution
        JM® Shipping Solution
      • Integrators
      Shipping Protection
      • Integrators
    • Business Risk Management
        Business Risk Management
      • Water temp services
      • Board-up services
      • Storage transportation
      • Safety & security academy
      Asset protection & support
      • Water temp services
      • Board-up services
      • Storage transportation
      • Safety & security academy
    • Business Protection
      Business Insurance
      • Business Owners Policy
      • Jewelers Block
      • Commercial Umbrella
      • Claims
    • Shipping Protection
      JM® Shipping Solution
      • Integrators
    • Asset protection & support
      Business Risk Management
      • Water temp services
      • Board-up services
      • Storage transportation
      • Safety & security academy
  • Grow your business
      Grow your business
    • Jeweler Solutions
        Jeweler Solutions
      • Personal Insurance
      • JM® Care Plan
      • Jewelry Appraisal Solution
      • Integrators
      Revenue Generators
      • Personal Insurance
      • JM® Care Plan
      • Jewelry Appraisal Solution
      • Integrators
    • JM® Marketplace
    • Revenue Generators
      Jeweler Solutions
      • Personal Insurance
      • JM® Care Plan
      • Jewelry Appraisal Solution
      • Integrators
    • Buy diamonds
      JM® Marketplace
  • Resource center
      Resource center
    • All resources
        All resources
      • Insurance
      • Risk management
      • Revenue boosters
      • Buy & sell jewelry
      • Shipping
      • Downloads
      • Insurance
      • Risk management
      • Revenue boosters
      • Buy & sell jewelry
      • Shipping
      • Downloads
    • All resources
      • Insurance
      • Risk management
      • Revenue boosters
      • Buy & sell jewelry
      • Shipping
      • Downloads

Jewelry Insurance as low as

$5/mo

or $60 per year

  1. Home /
  2. Business Resource Center /
  3. Risk management /
  4. Theft Prevention for Jewelers: Warning Signs to Be Aware Of
brc_theft-prevention-for-jewelers_-warning-signs-to-be-aware-of
Risk management
Read: 4 min

Theft Prevention for Jewelers: Warning Signs to Be Aware Of

by Jewelers Mutual
Aug 13, 2021 8:14AM
Facebook
Reddit
X
LinkedIn
Copy Link
Email article
Summary

Recognizing behavioral red flags can help jewelers prevent theft before it happens.

  • Obvious signs include nervousness, cell phone use, and group dispersal.
  • Subtle cues include excessive interest in comparing items or storytelling.
  • Staff should be trained to spot and document suspicious behavior.

Theft (defined the Jewelers' Security Alliance as the taking of property without force or fear) is like the Trojan Horse of crimes in the jewelry industry.

History buffs know what I'm talking about. The heavily-secured fortress of a jewelry business gets compromised by a small army of savvy thieves disguised as customers.

In essence, state-of-the-art physical and electronic security get neutralized because procedural security fails to meet standards. It may sound far-fetched, but it happens all the time. Theft is the most preventable crime facing the jewelry industry, yet it  continues to lead the way in terms of the number of incidents.

Theft prevention for jewelers starts with knowing these warning signs preceding a crime:

 

The Obvious Signs

  • Appearing nervous or fidgety
  • Using a cell phone
  • Entering in a group and dispersing in the store

 

The Not-So-Obvious Signs

  • Asking to compare items
  • Telling a story
  • Interested in everything

 

Theft Warning Signs: The Obvious

Appearing Nervous or Fidgety

Even professional thieves had to start somewhere. It takes a lot of guts to steal something and it's hard to quell the human nature of rushing adrenaline while being in the hot seat.

A normal customer has no reason to be nervous. They should be excited — they're shopping for jewelry after all! If the associates at your business make customers uncomfortable, you might have problems other than theft prevention.

Pictured: Actual suspects wanted for theft in January 2017 as noted by the Jewelers' Security Alliance.

 

Using a Cell Phone

Cell phones have become the passive-aggressive way to say "I'm not interested" when a social setting takes a turn for the worst. You can do more than just fake a phone call — you can text no one in particular, check your email for something "important," or just surf the web when you don't want to be bothered.

Criminals know that our society is accustomed to leaving people on their phones alone, so they will use that to their advantage and strike when you've stopped paying attention to them completely.

 

Entering in a Group and Dispersing in the Store

The typically jewelry shopper is most likely either:

  • on a solo trip to find a gift to surprise a loved one, or
  • a couple deciding on jewelry together.

When groups of people split up in your store, it could be to form a distraction. Make sure there are enough associates available to properly serve each customer and don't feel bad if you have to tell someone to wait.


Theft Warning Signs: The Not-So-Obvious

Asking to Compare Items

So what? Wouldn't any logical customer want to look at two hard-to-choose items side-by-side before making their final decision? Sure, but criminals know this tactic is great for increasing their amount of loot because it doesn't distinguish them from a normal customer.

Make it a store policy to show only one item at a time. Regular customers will understand; criminals will have a harder time accepting it.

 

Telling a Story

In order to gain your trust, criminals may fabricate stories in order to get your guard down — the classic Trojan Horse!

These stories may end with a special request that could try to get you to break a store policy (like showing more than one item at a time). Stick to your plan and don't make accomodations, no matter how heartfelt the story may seem.

Remember: there's always a chance merchandise could be stolen until it's paid for.

 

Interested in Everything

Staying on a streak of practicing flawless procedural security is like a manufacturing plant that counts the number of days without an accident — it can't go on forever.

If a potential customer goes from showcase to showcase asking to try everything on, they could just be waiting for you to slip up.

They might tell you that they're a big spender in order to for the potential sale to blind you from practicing good procedures, but this in itself should raise a red flag. If they're bombarding you and you feel prone to making a security mistake, there's no shame in asking for assistance or additional security to stand nearby.

 

If each theft was as damaging to a jewelry business as the Greeks were to the city of Troy, the lesson would be learned quickly and the outcome probably wouldn't repeat itself.

While theft prevention of jewelers doesn't parallel the fall of empires, it can take a while for all of the associates at your business to be trained to recognize these nuances that precede crime. Kick your theft prevention up a notch and have them complete the Selling with Security course on JM University® today!

See related articles

How to prevent jewelry return fraud
Risk management
Read: 7 min
How to prevent jewelry return fraud
Stop costly jewelry return scams. Learn how to spot jewelry swap fraud, fake damage claims and hidden warning signs.
August 31, 2026
An extended recovery plan after a jewelry store robbery
Risk management
Read: 6 min
An extended recovery plan after a jewelry store robbery
Recovering from a jewelry store robbery takes a plan. Learn what to do after a robbery and how to manage claims.
August 10, 2026
brc_jewelry-trade-shows_-security-for-before-during-and-after
Risk management
Read: 2 min
Jewelry trade show security: Protecting your merchandise
Traveling with high-value inventory? Follow these before, during and after trade show security tips to help protect your merchandise all event season.
August 7, 2026
cl_jewelryburglar_shot11
Risk management
Read: 3 min
What to do before, during and after a jewelry store robbery
Prepare your jewelry store for the unexpected with guidance on robbery prevention, how to respond safely during an incident, and recovery steps afterward.
August 5, 2026
brc_what-to-know-about-anti-money-laundering-certification-for-jewelers
Risk management
Read: 4 min
What to know about Anti-Money Laundering certification for jewelers
Learn who must comply with Anti-Money Laundering laws, what annual AML certification requires, and the penalties for non-compliance.
August 4, 2026
1 / 1

Footer

Footer social navigation

Facebook TikTok X Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
  • Protect your business
  • Business Insurance
  • Business Risk Management
  • JM® Shipping Solution
  • Grow your business
  • Zing® Jewelry Marketplace
  • Jeweler Solutions
  • Resource center

Legal Menu

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Notice at Collection
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Automated Decision Making Technology Notice

© 2026 Jewelers Mutual Group - All Rights Reserved

Insurance coverage is subject to underwriting review and approval, and to the actual policy terms and conditions. Any descriptions are a brief summary of coverage and are not part of any policies, nor a substitute for the actual policy language. Coverage options may vary by state and by product. Exclusions and limitations may apply.

Insurance coverage is offered by a member insurer of the Jewelers Mutual Group, either Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company, SI (a stock insurer) or JM Specialty Insurance Company, or otherwise via other carriers through JM Insurance Agency Partners, Inc. Policyholders of Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company, SI and JM Specialty Insurance Company are members of Jewelers Mutual Holding Company.